The Effect of Wealth On the Human Soul— Part I.

“What is clear about rich people and their money— and becoming ever clearer— is how it changes them.  A body of quirky but persuasive research has sought to understand the effects of wealth and privilege on human behavior— and any future book about the nature of billionaires would do well to consult it.

One especially fertile source is the University of California at Berkeley psychology department lab overseen by a professor named Dacher Keltner.  In one study, Keltner and his colleague Paul Piff installed note takers and cameras at city street intersections with four-way Stop signs.  The people driving expensive cars were four times more likely to cut in front of other drivers than drivers of cheap cars.  The researchers then followed the drivers to the city’s crosswalks and positioned themselves as pedestrians, waiting to cross the street.  The drivers in the cheap cars all respected the pedestrians’ right of way.  The drivers in the expensive cars ignored the pedestrians 46.2 percent of the time— a finding that was replicated ...by another team of researchers in Manhattan, who found drivers of expensive cars were far more likely to double-park.

In yet another study, the Berkeley researchers invited a cross section of the population into their lab and marched them through a series of tasks.  Upon leaving the laboratory testing room, the subjects passed a big jar of candy.  The richer the person, the more likely he was to reach in and take candy from the jar— and ignore the big sign on the jar that said the candy was for the children who passed through the department.

Maybe my favorite study done by the Berkeley team rigged a game with cash prizes in favor of one of the players, and then showed how that person, as he grows richer, becomes more likely to cheat.  In his forthcoming book on power, Keltner contemplates his findings:

If I have $100,000.00 in my bank account, winning $50 alters my personal wealth in trivial fashion.  It just isn’t that big of a deal.  If I have $84 in my bank account, winning $50 not only changes my personal wealth significantly, it matters in terms of the quality of my life— the extra $50 determines what bill I might be able to pay, what I might put in my refrigerator at the end of the month, the kind of date I would go out on, or whether or not I could buy a beer for a friend.  The value of winning $50 is greater for the poor, and, by implication, the incentive for lying in our study greater.  Yet it was our wealthy participants who were far more likely to lie for the chance of winning fifty bucks.

There is plenty more like this to be found, if you look for it.  A team of researchers at the New York Psychiatric Institute surveyed 43,000 Americans and found that, by some wide margin, the rich were more likely to shoplift than the poor.  Another study, by a coalition of non-profits called the Independent Sector, revealed that people with incomes below 25 grand give away, on average, 4.2 percent of their income, while those earning more than 150 grand a year give away only 2.7 percent.  A UCLA neuroscientist named Keely Muscatell has published an interesting paper showing that wealth quiets the nerves in the brain associated with empathy: If you show rich people and poor people pictures of kids with cancer, the poor people’s brains exhibit a great deal more activity than the rich people’s....  ‘As you move up the class ladder,’ says Keltner, ‘you are more likely to violate the rules of the road, to lie, to cheat, to take candy from kids, to shoplift, and to be tightfisted in giving to others.  Straightforward economic analyses have trouble making sense of this pattern of results.’”

I bet they do.  God, however, does not.  He said, “People who want to get rich fall into temptation and a trap, and into many foolish and harmful desires that plunge men into destruction.  For the love of money is a root of all kinds of evil” {1 Timothy 6:9-10b}.

HJC	Ric Webb  |  Shepherd Heart’s Journey Community 9621 Tall Timber Blvd. |  Little Rock, AR 72204 t +1.501.455.0296
hjcommunity.org
Heart’s Journey – Live Generously and Love Graciously